A few years ago, I found myself in a conversation with someone skeptical of Montessori education. He had a critical take: he believed Montessori tends to produce children who are too stubborn, too argumentative, and overly insistent on doing things their own way. I had to admit—there’s some truth to that. A child raised in a Montessori environment might very well show those traits. But I had to ask: why do we assume that’s a bad thing?
As a culture, it’s time we reexamine our views of the so-called “stubborn child.” A compliant, agreeable child is undeniably easier to raise—easier to manage in the daily rhythm of family life, easier to present in social situations, more likely to win praise from peers and adults alike. Such a child is often called “good.” But does that mean the strong-willed, challenging child is “bad”?
We don’t think so.
In fact, we believe that the very qualities that frustrate us in our children during difficult moments—their defiance, persistence, and need to assert themselves—can be among their greatest strengths. If nurtured and guided properly, those traits become tools for success. Consider how we label strong-willed children: “stubborn,” “disobedient,” “defiant.” Now compare that with the way we describe successful adults who show the same traits: “determined,” “resilient,” “tenacious,” “driven.”
That stubborn streak? Think of it as a powerful motor—one that doesn’t need to be silenced, but directed. Children don’t need to suppress their will; they need to learn how to harness it. This capacity for self-regulation, for channeling internal strength with purpose, is what psychologists today call “executive functioning.” It’s a cornerstone of modern developmental science—and Montessori recognized its importance over a century ago. Her ideas about self-mastery, discipline, and “true obedience” remain central to our educational approach today.
So, if you’re parenting a strong-willed, oppositional child—one who argues, challenges, and insists on doing things their own way—take a deep breath. This is a good thing. Be proud of her. Be hopeful about her future. And keep reading for encouragement, perspective, and practical strategies to help you navigate the rough patches—so you can support her growth, and help her turn that strength into something extraordinary.
Get A Free Ebook: My Liberty Ends Where Yours Begins
The strong-willed child craves autonomy. She wants to make choices, to control her actions, to have her voice heard. She needs to feel that her decisions matter—and that they’re respected.
These are fundamentally human desires. We all want autonomy and recognition; we simply differ in how strongly we feel those needs, and in how effectively we can get them met. Some children—more naturally compliant or eager to please—might be satisfied with less freedom, or may place a higher value on parental approval. But a stubborn child’s intensity doesn’t make her irrational or “too much.” Her needs are real and valid.
That said, respecting a child’s nature doesn’t mean letting her mistreat others, dominate peers, or behave disrespectfully. But we cannot teach her kindness, cooperation, or empathy by punishing her for being strong-willed. Our job as parents and educators is not to control, but to guide. We are not masters or owners of our children—we are mentors, role models, and partners in their growth.
In Montessori, we return again and again to the same simple principles:
- The best way to learn is by doing.
- The best way to teach is through thoughtful, prepared experience.
- And the best way to inspire positive behavior is to model it.
Understanding Stubborn Behavior in Children
Before you can address stubbornness, it’s essential to understand why children become stubborn in the first place. Stubborn behavior can be a form of communication — a way for a child to express independence, unmet emotional needs, or resistance to feeling controlled.
Common Reasons for Stubborn Behavior:
- Desire for independence
- Seeking attention
- Lack of emotional vocabulary
- Developmental stage (especially common in toddlers and teens)
- Stress or overstimulation
- Inconsistent boundaries at home
Stubbornness vs. Strong-Willed Behavior
Not all stubbornness is negative. Many children who are labeled “stubborn” are actually strong-willed, meaning they are determined, passionate, and often have a strong sense of justice or right and wrong. When guided correctly, these qualities can evolve into leadership and resilience.
Effective Strategies to Deal with a Stubborn Child at Home
1. Stay Calm and Consistent
Reacting emotionally often escalates the situation. Staying calm shows your child that their behavior won’t shake your authority or emotional state.
- Speak in a neutral, calm tone.
- Avoid yelling or threatening, which may backfire.
- Consistency builds trust and reduces testing of boundaries.
2. Offer Limited Choices
Giving your child a sense of control can reduce power struggles.
Instead of: “Put on your shoes now!”
Try: “Would you like to wear the red shoes or the blue ones?”
This tactic shifts the focus from confrontation to cooperation.
3. Set Clear Expectations and Boundaries
Children thrive on structure. Stubborn children, in particular, need to understand the rules and consequences clearly.
- Use simple, age-appropriate language.
- Make sure both parents or caregivers are on the same page.
- Follow through with consequences.
4. Use Positive Reinforcement
Praise and reward good behavior instead of always focusing on what your child does wrong.
- Celebrate small victories.
- Use sticker charts, high-fives, or extra playtime as incentives.
- Be specific in your praise: “You listened the first time I asked. That was awesome!”
5. Model the Behavior You Want
Children learn by watching. If you lose your temper or ignore rules, your child is likely to mimic that behavior.
- Show respect, patience, and calmness, especially during conflict.
- Apologize when you’re wrong — it teaches accountability.
6. Listen Actively
Sometimes, what appears to be stubbornness is actually a cry for attention or feeling misunderstood.
- Get down to their eye level.
- Use phrases like, “I hear that you’re upset,” or “Tell me what’s bothering you.”
- Don’t interrupt or try to “fix” their emotions too quickly.
7. Avoid Power Struggles
Power struggles often happen when a child feels powerless. Ask yourself:
- Is this issue really worth a battle?
- Can I let them choose how to do something instead of forcing them?
8. Use Time-Outs Thoughtfully
Time-outs can be effective but should not feel like punishment. Use them to give your child space to calm down and reflect.
- One minute per year of age is a good guideline.
- Explain the reason before and after the time-out.
9. Stay Emotionally Connected
Spending quality time together strengthens your relationship and reduces defiant behavior.
- Read books, play games, and listen without an agenda.
- Make time every day for bonding, no matter how small.
Dealing with Stubborn Behavior by Age
Toddlers (1–3 years)
- Use distraction and redirection.
- Keep routines predictable.
- Use very short, simple commands.
Preschoolers (3–5 years)
- Use stories to teach lessons.
- Create visual charts for chores or routines.
- Offer frequent praise.
School-Age Children (6–12 years)
- Involve them in rule-setting.
- Ask them to help come up with solutions to problems.
- Acknowledge their opinions and independence.
Teenagers (13–18 years)
- Treat them with respect and maturity.
- Allow more freedom within boundaries.
- Keep lines of communication open.
Things to Avoid When Dealing with a Stubborn Child
- Yelling or shaming
- Threatening punishments you won’t follow through on
- Ignoring their feelings
- Punishing emotions instead of actions
- Being inconsistent between caregivers or parents
Self-Care for Mums
Dealing with a strong-willed child can be emotionally taxing. It’s important to take care of yourself too:
- Take breaks when needed.
- Talk to other mums or join support groups.
- Seek help from a child psychologist or counselor if needed.
- Remember: You’re doing your best, and that’s enough.
FAQs: Dealing with a Stubborn Child at Home
Is being stubborn a sign of a behavioral disorder?
Not necessarily. Many children show stubborn behavior as part of normal development. However, if the behavior is extreme, persistent, or interfering with daily life, consult a pediatrician or child therapist.
How can I discipline a stubborn child without yelling?
Use calm, firm communication, set clear consequences, and offer choices. Positive reinforcement and natural consequences often work better than punishment.
What do I do if my child argues about everything?
Stay consistent and pick your battles. Let them win small decisions when appropriate, and avoid turning every disagreement into a lecture or debate.
How can I improve communication with my stubborn child?
Listen actively, validate their feelings, and give them time to express themselves. Try to stay calm and approachable, even during tough conversations.
When should I seek professional help?
If your child’s behavior is causing harm, disrupting family life significantly, or linked to anxiety or aggression, it’s wise to consult a child psychologist or pediatric specialist.
Conclusion: Embrace the Challenge, Empower Your Child
Raising a stubborn child isn’t easy, but it’s also an opportunity to raise a confident, determined, and emotionally intelligent human being. With the right approach, patience, and consistency, you can guide your child through their emotions and help them channel their strong will into positive action.
Remember, you’re not alone in this journey. Trust your instincts, stay calm, and reach out for support when needed. You’ve got this, mum!
References
- American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). (2022). Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children.
https://www.aap.org - Siegel, D. J., & Bryson, T. P. (2012). The Whole-Brain Child: 12 Revolutionary Strategies to Nurture Your Child’s Developing Mind.
Bantam Books. - National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2021). Child Development and Behavior Resources.
https://www.nichd.nih.gov - Kurcinka, M. S. (2015). Raising Your Spirited Child: A Guide for Parents Whose Child Is More Intense, Sensitive, and Persistent.
HarperCollins. - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2023). Parenting Tips by Age.
https://www.cdc.gov/parents